Questions
Questions answered
Here are the questions people most often ask themselves when they decide to play together. Some are about the line-up and where to meet, others about rehearsals and sound, others about gigs and recordings. Each answer fits into a few sentences and is a starting point; you'll find fuller explanations in the sections, the article on the first rehearsal and the glossary. We write about hearing only in general terms, and about authors' rights too, with no legal promises. If your question isn't here, take a look at the collections: a similar situation may be covered there step by step.
Most questions from a new band boil down to “is it like this for everyone?”. Usually yes: playing tightly together doesn't come at once. But a few things are better thought about before they become a problem.
Line-up and space
Can we start a band if nobody can really play?
Yes. Many line-ups started with people who knew a couple of chords. What matters more is that everyone wants to learn and turns up regularly. Choose simple songs and practise at home, and at rehearsal learn to hear each other.
What if the line-up is missing a drummer or a bassist?
Start with who you have. You can keep the rhythm with a metronome or tap it out on something quiet, and play the bass part on a guitar in a lower register for now. Meanwhile, tell people who you're looking for: the right person is often found through mutual friends.
Where is it better to rehearse — at home or in a rehearsal room?
It depends on the task. Working out parts and coming up with ideas is easy at home, quietly and without rushing. Playing at full volume with drums is better in a rehearsal room, where the walls are built for it. A garage is somewhere in between, if there are no homes right next to it.
How do we come to an agreement with the neighbours?
Meet them in person, tell them when you plan to play and give them a way to contact you. Respect quiet hours and finish on time. If the neighbours complain, don't argue — ask what time suits them better and think about another place for loud sessions.
Rehearsals and sound
Why do we sound worse together than each of us does at home?
At home you only hear yourself, but in a band you have to listen to the others and adjust. Usually the problem is too much volume, different tempos and a poor setup. Play quieter, stand in a semicircle and try the song more slowly.
How often should we rehearse?
Regularity matters more than frequency. One meeting a week that everyone attends does more than several that fall through. Between rehearsals everyone practises at home, so you're not learning parts from scratch when you meet.
Do we need earplugs if we don't play very loud?
Even a not-very-loud rehearsal in a small room tires your ears, especially near the drums. Musicians' earplugs reduce sound evenly, so music stays clear. Take quiet breaks, and if your ears ring after a session and it doesn't go away, see a doctor.
How do we argue about music without falling out?
Talk about the sound and the song, not the person: “the guitar is covering the voice here”, not “you're too loud again”. Let everyone have their say and try the disputed options one after another, recording both. If the argument hits a dead end, put it off until the next meeting.
Gigs and recordings
When is a band ready to play live?
When you can confidently play a short set all the way through without stopping, and you're not afraid of slipping up in one place. An open mic or a school evening is a good place to start: people there expect live playing, not mastery.
Can we play only our own songs at a gig?
Of course. Your own material gives the band its identity, though listeners who don't know you sometimes find it easier when the set includes a couple of familiar songs. It's your call, but play what you're confident in.
How do we record a demo without a studio?
Choose a quiet room, place a phone away from the drums and play the song all the way through several times. Listen to the takes the next day with fresh ears and choose the one with the most life, not the smoothest.
Can we post a recording of a cover?
Every song has authors, and their rights still apply when you play someone else's song your own way. The rules for publishing recordings differ from those for live performance and depend on where you want to post the recording. We don't give legal opinions; check the terms with the people responsible for the platform.
Read next
- Sections
A map of the guide: line-up and agreements, rehearsals, sound and hearing, stage and recording.
- Guides
How to run your band's first rehearsal: preparation, steps with examples, mistakes, fallback options and a checklist. The article catalogue is here too.
- Reference
An amateur musician's glossary: run-through, setlist, arrangement, metronome, monitor, balance, soundcheck, rider, demo, cover.
- Collections
Reading routes: neighbours and volume, a home demo with what you have, getting ready for your first gig.
Sources
- Hearing protection recommendations for musicians (in general terms)
- Editorial materials of the guide
Everything said here about volume and hearing is general advice, not medical guidance. Musicians' earplugs and quiet breaks help many people, but they don't solve everything. If your ears ring after a rehearsal or gig and it doesn't go away, don't wait: see a doctor. For questions about authors' rights and the terms of a particular venue, check with the people responsible for them.